Aarhus Universitets segl

Kasper Lippert-Rasmussen keynote speaker at the Second Conference of the European Moral Responsibility Consortium (EMRC)

On September 30 Kasper Lippert-Rasmussen gave a Keynote at the Second Conference of the European Moral Responsibility Consortium (EMRC) on "The Nature of Oppressive Praise and Grounds of Praiseworthiness".

When does praise become opressive? Can doing the wrong thing still make you praiseworthy? - Can a person be genuinely praiseworthy even when the praise they receive reinforces oppressive expectations?

In this keynote Kasper Lippert-Rasmussen connects recent philosophical debates on structural oppression, discrimination, and moral responsibility, while advancing a new account of oppressive praise and praiseworthiness. 

Abstract: In recent years, philosophers have increasingly turned their attention to malign forms of praise. This paper focuses on one particular subtype: oppressive praise. It first argues that existing definitions are inadequate and proposes a new one that distinguishes, among other things, between praise that is oppressive because it reflects oppressive norms and praise that is oppressive because it (re)produces such norms. It also distinguishes between oppressive tokens of praise and oppressive types of praise. These distinctions underpin the paper’s second main contribution: an account of what does not make oppressive praise objectionable. Specifically, I argue that recipients of oppressive praise may, despite the oppressive nature of the praise they receive, be genuinely praiseworthy for what they do. This claim rests on a more general account of praiseworthiness – third main claim of the paper – according to which, among other things, an agent may be praiseworthy for acting better—or simply less badly—than typical members of the relevant reference group in similar circumstances. Accordingly, agents may be praiseworthy even for wrongful actions, provided that those actions are less bad than the actions that typical members of the relevant reference group would have performed in the same situation.

The conference was held from September 28-30, 2026, at the Department of Philosophy, University of Salzburg, Austria. It was organised by Leonhard Menges and Leonie Eichhorn and the Salzburg Ethics Group as part of the FWF-funded project "Skepticism about Praiseworthiness", with the aim to facilitate coordination and cooperation among philosophers in Europe working on moral responsibility and related topics.